Guest Blog: Umbrella Industry Non-Compliance - What You Need to Know About Government Consultations

3 min

The umbrella industry, which involves companies that provide services to contractors, freelancers, and temporary workers, has been under increased scrutiny due to concerns surrounding non-compliance with government regulations. In recent years, various stakeholders have expressed their concerns regarding the lack of transparency, tax evasion, and the exploitation of workers within this sector. To address these issues, the government has initiated consultations and introduced reforms to bring the umbrella industry into compliance with the law. In this blog, Parasol, explores the nuances of non-compliance in the umbrella industry and the ongoing government consultation aimed at rectifying these concerns.

Understanding the Umbrella Industry

Before delving into non-compliance issues, it's essential to grasp the role of the umbrella industry. Umbrella companies act as intermediaries between contractors and their end clients. These companies handle payroll, taxes, and employment-related responsibilities on behalf of contractors, allowing them to work flexibly while receiving the benefits of full employment status. Parasol, part of the wider Caroola Group, has been one of the largest and most well respected umbrella companies in the industry since its inception in 2000.

Non-Compliance Challenges

Tax Avoidance: One of the major issues in the umbrella industry is tax avoidance. Some umbrella companies have been reported to be exploiting loopholes in tax regulations to reduce their contractors' tax liability. This not only undermines the government's tax revenue but also leaves workers at risk of future financial liabilities.

Lack of Transparency: Non-compliance often arises due to a lack of transparency in how umbrella companies operate. Contractors may not fully understand their tax obligations or how their earnings are calculated. This opacity makes it difficult for workers to make informed decisions.

Worker Exploitation: Some umbrella companies have been reported to be engaging in practices that exploit workers, such as underpaying them or withholding benefits. This exploitation can lead to financial instability and damage the overall wellbeing of the workforce.

Government Consultation and Reforms

To address these non-compliance issues, the UK government has initiated consultations aimed at bringing more oversight and transparency to the umbrella industry. The consultation process includes input from stakeholders, including umbrella companies, contractors, and industry experts.

Key Areas of Focus:

Legislation and Regulation: The government is looking to regulate the industry by introducing legislation that will clarify the roles and responsibilities of umbrella companies, making it easier to hold them accountable for non-compliance.

Enhanced Reporting and Transparency: Umbrella companies will be required to provide more detailed reports to contractors, allowing them to better understand how their earnings are calculated and how tax is handled.

Worker Protections: Reforms will focus on protecting workers from exploitation by setting minimum wage standards and ensuring that they receive employment benefits like holiday pay and sick pay.

Tax Enforcement: Enhanced measures will be implemented to combat tax avoidance, ensuring that umbrella companies comply with tax regulations.

Benefits of Compliance

The proposed reforms aim to create a more transparent, equitable, and compliant umbrella industry. Compliance within this sector benefits not only the government but also contractors and umbrella companies themselves:

Improved Worker Wellbeing: Compliance measures protect workers' rights, ensuring they receive fair compensation and employment benefits.

Reduced Tax Evasion: Compliance helps to bridge the tax gap and ensures that the government receives its fair share of revenue.

Enhanced Industry Reputation: A compliant umbrella industry builds trust among contractors and clients, ultimately strengthening the sector's reputation.


Non-compliance in the umbrella industry has raised significant concerns, necessitating government intervention. The ongoing government consultation and proposed reforms seek to create a more transparent, accountable, and equitable sector. As a founding member of FCSA, Parasol & Caroola Accountancy have been at the forefront of promoting compliance within the industry for many years.

Achieving compliance in the umbrella industry will not only benefit the government but also protect the rights and wellbeing of workers while enhancing the industry's overall reputation. As the consultation process unfolds, it is crucial for all stakeholders to actively participate and contribute to shaping a more compliant and ethical umbrella industry. Therefore, Parasol & Caroola Accountancy will continue to take an active role in responding to the consultation, as well as supporting both employment businesses and end clients in the run-up to and implementation of the final legislation, which is expected by April 2024.